We're not kitten around: cats are nutty for our range of organic, made-in-USA catnip toys

Christmas & Hanukkah


21 products
  • Large
    $10.98
    $10.98
  • Cat Charmer Christmas Colors from Cat Supplies & More
    $5.99
    $5.99
  • Cat'n Around Sam Snowman w/Catnip from Cat Supplies and More
    Sold out
    $5.95
  • Red and green Christmas Braided Mice with Rattle from Cat Supplies & More
    $3.19
    $3.19
  • Christmas Rags to Riches Mice and Balls Cat Toys from Cat Supplies and More
    Sold out
    $4.49
  • Christmas Red and Green Terry Mice 2-Pack from Cat Supplies and More
    Sold out
    $3.49
  • Christmas Stocking 17
    $14.99
    $14.99
  • Holiday Glitter Pom Cat Toys 4-Pack from Cat Supplies & More
    Sold out
    $2.49
  • I've Been Almost Purrfect Holiday Stocking from Cat Supplies and More
    $7.99
    $7.99
  • Jewish Gelt Catnip Toy from Cat Supplies and More
    $4.29
    $4.29
  • Lupine Winter & Christmas themed cat collar with bell
    $10.49
    $10.49
  • Ratherbee Christmas 2
    $3.39
    $3.39
  • Ratherbee Christmas 4
    $5.59
    $5.59
  • Ratherbee Christmas 6
    $7.19
    $7.19
  • Ratherbee Christmas Candy Cane Catnip Toy
    $7.09
    $7.09